Despite public concerns about impact of potential flooding on Davenport’s $27-million Main Street Landing riverfront project, a city architect thinks the fears are not justified.
Zach Peterson, Professional Landscape Architect for the city of Davenport, gave a presentation on MSL (under construction since April 2025) on Thursday, Nov. 19 at Riverdale City Hall, presented by the Quad Cities Flood Resiliency Alliance.
Launched in 2018, the QC Flood Resiliency Alliance brings together communities, local governments, emergency management, and public works personnel to prepare for, respond to, and recover from floods. It also works to reduce flood insurance costs for residents and businesses.
When completed, visitors can enter the new park near Dillon Fountain on Main Street by taking the pedestrian bridge 25 feet up and over the railroad tracks.
You'll be greeted by river-inspired flowing pathways leading to the shaded pavilions, a multi-use space set up for pickleball, an outdoor skating rink and sport court, or the adventure playground with water features and roller dam slides. As the park stretches to the east, there is more green space and a hillside overlook with native plants.
No local taxpayer dollars are being used to build Main Street Landing. Instead, the entire program ($27.3 million) will be paid for using special-use funding that can only be spent for this purpose, according to the city.
“The Mississippi is going to do what it's going to do,” Peterson said Thursday. “So as far as our site location is concerned, the city of Davenport is blessed with nine miles of public riverfront. It's home of the three national trails that go through the riverfront, and the star there is the Main Street Landing site.
"It's here, it's kind of like the center point of and showcase space of our nine miles of riverfront. What's great about it, you know, the river here is unique in that it goes from east to west, so it's great in that it provides us with southern exposure to everything, and Rock Island gets a pretty cool backdrop.”
Peterson on Thursday said the city practices “passive flood resistance,” instead of building a flood wall that would obscure views of the river.
“It involves strategic elevation and floodproofing of key assets, providing support services to affected property, private property owners and continued expansion of marshland allowing flood inundation and natural mitigation,” he said.
“We do it to make the river a river. By doing so, it preserves the intimate access, the sightlines, and views of the river, which is arguably the finest asset that we have going for us here in Davenport and the greater Quad Cities.”
“And we're good stewards in Davenport, as opposed to we could throw up a levee and pass off the problem downstream,” he said. “So why we do it is that we kind of find it arguably our finest asset. It's a junction of environmental, economic, and social reasons why we're doing riverfront-based projects and whatnot.”
“The key strategies to flood resiliency is a three-pronged approach of retreat, mitigation, and active flood fighting,” Peterson said, noting the cost of a permanent flood wall would be $163 million, compared to $350,000 the city would pay to handle each flood event, including putting up HESCO barriers.
Main Street Landing is being built at a higher elevation, and Peterson showed how flood stages would affect the riverfront park, at 19-foot river levels, as well as 21 and 22 feet. The 2019 record flood reached 22.64 feet and spring 2023 flooding exceeded 21 feet.
“I want to point out active flood fighting takes place in a very small portion of our riverfront in the lower right-hand corner there where the elevations are lower, inundating what's kind of now the Motor Row area as well,” he said. “The tool of choice is the HESCO barrier. So when done correctly, this is a very cost-effective flood fighting mitigation effort.”
“In 2019, it brought new calls to revisit the idea of a permanent flood solution, and our consultant team with HR Green was taken on board. Findings: structural flood mitigation is expensive,” Peterson said. “It's an investment of $162.9 million.
"So you factor that in with our flood events, average cost of $350,000 for closing off each time. So it's roughly 465 flood events of that stature equals one flood wall.”
Much of Main Street Landing would remain dry in flood events, Peterson said.
“With estimated river flood of 17, 18, the site starts getting inundated. 19, most of the higher-level finishes are still high and dry in such a situation,” he said. “And then we start getting into more serious flood aspects. Flood level 21, the area with the sport court (ice rink) is still high and dry.
"It goes away roughly about 22. So this is roughly between here and here is the worst flooding. ever experienced. But when you think about when we hit our flood crest, it's a few hours at a time. It's not like we're having days at this elevation.
“So think about the mall parking lot and designing parking for Black Friday. It doesn't really make sense. So retailers are totally different. But it's designed to accommodate most percentage of flood,” Peterson said. “Once we're at 23, we've never experienced this level, but our fixtures, our restroom complex is still high and dry out of this, and the playground itself, the upper portions and overlook areas are still high and dry.
In a city FAQ on Main Street Landing on its website, it explains the big project is the result of decades of planning, and public outreach was a significant part of that process, Peterson noted.
Online surveys asked for opinions on specific ways to spend federal dollars coming from the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA). The city received more than $40 million to be allocated by the end of 2024. Main Street Landing accounts for $6 million (15%) of the city’s ARPA funds. (Note: Road maintenance and repairs were not allowable expenses for ARPA funds.)
The city also did three phases of outreach specifically focusing on Main Street Landing, including questions about features, designs, colors, and other elements.
In August 2022, November 2022, and August 2023, the city solicited public feedback at events including the Freight House Farmers Market, River Bandits games, Alternating Currents, and in-school activities. Three rounds of public surveys also generated 1,300 responses.
All of the input received contributed to the Main Street Landing plan. Overall, people said they wanted a public riverfront that is accessible to all. They also wanted to see this area become a Midwest destination that would complement the downtown, with places to play, relax, and enjoy the beauty of the Mississippi River.
Flood mapping played a major role in planning for the park. The maps on the city website show the four-season space (gray), restroom and pavilion (yellow), and play areas (green) elevated high enough to avoid being impacted by a 21-foot river level.
While some grassy space will be impacted, and access will be cut off, these areas are protected from being underwater for extended periods of time. It isn’t until the river hits 22 feet that these features begin to be impacted.
However, they are built with materials made to withstand flood conditions and can be easily cleaned and recovered. Since January 2020, the city has experienced only four days (out of 1,903) over river stage 21.
To see the complete answers to frequently asked questions, updates, and renderings of the completed project, visit https://www.davenportiowa.com/news/what_s_new/f_a_qs__main_street_landing.
While the city planned for the project to be done at the end of this year, a grand opening is not planned until the spring. The new ice rink would not be available until the 2027-28 winter season.
This story was produced by WVIK, Quad Cities NPR. We rely on financial support from our listeners and readers to provide coverage of the issues that matter to the Quad Cities region and beyond. As someone who values the content created by WVIK's news department, please consider making a financial contribution to support our work.