© 2026 WVIK
Listen at 90.3 FM and 98.3 FM in the Quad Cities, 95.9 FM in Dubuque, or on the WVIK app!
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

REVIEW: 'An Old Fashioned Family Murder' continues at Richmond Hill Players Barn Theatre in Geneseo

Jack Sellers, Shyan DeVoss, and Jesslyn Cohen in An Old-Fashioned Family Murder
Richmond Hill Players Barn Theatre's Facebook page
Jack Sellers, Shyan DeVoss, and Jesslyn Cohen in An Old-Fashioned Family Murder

The Quad Cities’ theatre scene is winding down opening new shows this past weekend in anticipation of wrapping things up for the holidays. Kicking off first is Richmond Hill Players’ final production for 2026: Joe DiPietro’s comedy An Old Fashioned Family Murder directed by RHP’s President of the Board, Jonathan Grafft.

The program summary reads: “On a dark and stormy night at the mansion of elderly Colonel Claythorne, Arthur Whittington, the murder mystery author, holds court with the Colonel’s family, including his eldest daughter, Clarice, her fiancé, Jasper Jamison, the Colonel’s youngest daughter Dotty, and Mrs. Shirley Peck, a visiting widow. When Whittington shares the news that the Colonel has modified his will to cut out one of his daughters – though which daughter won’t be revealed until the Colonel’s death – tempers flare. By the time Mrs. Peck’s son Detective Paul Peck, Jr. arrives, there’s been a murder, and everyone is a suspect. It soon becomes clear nothing – and no one – is what it or [they] seem.”

Mrs. Peck is the widow of Detective Paul Peck, Sr., the area’s former investigator extraordinaire who has a long list of solved murders. Peck, Jr., who lives under the shadow of his dad’s success, arrives to pick up his mother and instead discovers the murdered body.

The inept investigation that ensues reveals Peck, Jr. is clearly not as competent as his dad. To his chagrin, Mrs. Peck interprets the clues in true “Murder, She Wrote” Jessica Fletcher fashion, ultimately solving the crime.

Taking on the role of the impeccable Mrs. Peck is the Skiles’ family matriarch Jackie Skiles and she imbues her character with a sweet, adorable persona that you just can’t help but love. Mothers in the audience will instantly relate to her. Unlike the bumbling Peck, Jr., Samuel Carrington is waggishly adept in his portrayal of the character and Mike Kelly brings his comic A-game as the arrogant, supercilious Arthur Whittington.

The action takes place in the 1940’s and the set elicits that vibe but screams for an area rug to tie the set together. I understand that there may be concern about a tripping hazard, but seasoned actors like those in this production are certainly capable of handling themselves on stage. Another thing – and I’ve observed this in multiple venues – is the apparent aversion to the use of an iron on costumes. It rankles to see obvious shipping package creases in costumes – and other fabric props for that matter. Attention to detail is what elevates a production.

An Old Fashioned Family Murder continues at Richmond Hill Players Barn Theatre in Geneseo, Thursday through Saturday, November 19 through 21 at 7:30 p.m. and Sunday, November 22 at 3:00 p.m.

I’m Chris Hicks… break a leg.