What's The Deal With Iceland?
Iceland's latest volcanic eruption and the cloud of ash drifting over Europe are proving to be hugely costly and disruptive but, so far, the effects are mild compared with the havoc caused by the country's economic eruption just a year and a half ago.
As if on cue, Iceland's Eyjafjallajokull volcano erupted in the same week as the release of a long-awaited report from the investigation into the country's financial collapse.
The collapse of Iceland's major banks in late 2008 helped herald the start of the worldwide financial crisis. It brought the country's government to the brink of bankruptcy and wiped out billions of dollars worth of savings for bank customers in other countries.
What is it with Iceland? How can a remote island in the North Atlantic, with only about 320,000 people, be the source of so much damage?
An Increasingly Interconnected World
If the drifting ash from Iceland's volcano shows the interconnected nature of weather and ecological systems around the world, the fallout from Iceland's bank failures shows the interconnectedness of global financial systems.
This week's report accuses Iceland's former prime minister and other top officials of "gross negligence" for failing to intervene as the country's three biggest banks took on the excessive debt that eventually sucked them under.
The investigation was carried out by a commission appointed by Iceland's Althing, or Parliament. The lawmakers must now decide whether to take legal action against former Prime Minister Geir Haarde and other top officials.
Meanwhile, Iceland's economy remains mired in recession and experts say it could be years before the country recovers.
"The country is still in crisis," says Fridrik Mar Baldursson, a professor of economics at Reykjavik University. He says foreign investment in Iceland has dried up, largely because of uncertainty over whether Iceland will get the next installment of a crucial loan from the International Monetary Fund.
Iceland's bank meltdown began in late 2008, not long after the collapse of Lehman Brothers in the United States. The country's three biggest banks collapsed and were taken over by the government, which found itself with a combined debt that was many times the size of its entire economy.
The problem might not have been so serious if it were confined to Iceland. But the crisis was compounded by the fact that Iceland's banks had been snapping up assets around the world.
The country's biggest bank, Landsbanki, had also been offering online savings accounts, through a subsidiary known as Icesave, to hundreds of thousands of customers in the U.K. and the Netherlands.
When the bank went belly up, those customers saw their savings wiped out.
The British and Dutch governments eventually stepped in to compensate their citizens who lost money in Icesave, but now they want the Icelandic government to pay them back a total of $5.3 billion. They argue that the government of Iceland was obligated to guarantee at least part of those savings accounts, much as the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. guarantees bank accounts in the U.S.
Icelanders Reject Repayment
The Icelandic public resents what it sees as a punitive demand for repayment by the British and Dutch. In a national referendum in March, Icelanders rejected a payment plan negotiated by the government.
Last year, the IMF and the Nordic countries of Finland, Norway and Denmark agreed to help bail Iceland out with a loan package worth about $4.5 billion.
The IMF's contribution is being delayed, in part because of Iceland's dispute with the U.K. and the Netherlands. The IMF's board is expected to meet Friday to review the issue and decide whether to pay out more of the loan. That would free up more of the money from the Nordic countries as well.
In the meantime, says Baldursson, much of Iceland's economy is at a standstill.
"Iceland in many ways is very fortunate," he says. "We have a lot of natural resources — geothermal and hydroelectric energy — and there's a lot of foreign interest in investing in energy projects, but the markets don't want to lend money until the disputes are resolved."
Earlier this month, Moody's Investor Service downgraded Iceland's debt ratings from "stable" to "negative," making it still more difficult for the country to raise money overseas.
Oddly, Baldursson says that to look at Reykjavik today, a foreigner wouldn't necessarily know that there's a problem.
"If you didn't know there was an economic crisis," he says, "you might think, 'What a thriving country!' "
He says the tourism sector is still strong, though that could be affected if volcanic ash continues to shut down travel across the North Atlantic. At around 9 percent, unemployment is considered extremely high for Iceland, "but most people are still employed, so they're getting by," Baldursson says.
Baldursson says that so far, the latest volcanic eruption has caused relatively little economic damage in Iceland itself.
"The eruption is not in an area where there's a big risk," he says. "Most of [the ash] is falling on other countries — most of it seems to be accruing on the U.K."
Copyright 2023 NPR. To see more, visit https://www.npr.org.